- 1962 : St. Lawrence 5-2 Clarkson
- 1963 : Harvard 4-3 (ot) Boston College
- 1964 : Providence 3-1 St. Lawrence
- 1965 : Boston College 6-2 Brown
- 1966 : Clarkson 6-2 Cornell
- 1967 : Cornell 4-3 Boston University
- 1968 : Cornell 6-3 Boston College
- 1969 : Cornell 4-2 Harvard
- 1970 : Cornell 3-2 Clarkson
- 1971 : Harvard 7-4 Clarkson
- 1972 : Boston University 4-1 Cornell
- 1973 : Cornell 3-2 Boston College
- 1974 : Boston University 4-2 Harvard
- 1975 : Boston University 7-3 Harvard
- 1976 : Boston University 9-2 Brown
- 1977 : Boston University 8-6 New Hampshire
- 1978 : Boston College 4-2 Providence
- 1979 : New Hampshire 3-2 Dartmouth
- 1980 : Cornell 5-1 Dartmouth
- 1981 : Providence 8-4 Cornell
- 1982 : Northeastern 5-2 Harvard
- 1983 : Harvard 4-1 Providence
- 1984 : Rensselaer 5-2 Boston University
| | - 1985 : Rensselaer 3-1 Harvard
- 1986 : Cornell 3-2 (ot) Clarkson
- 1987 : Harvard 6-3 St. Lawrence
- 1988 : St. Lawrence 3-0 Clarkson
- 1989 : St. Lawrence 4-1 Vermont
- 1990 : Colgate 5-4 Rensselaer
- 1991 : Clarkson 5-4 St. Lawrence
- 1992 : St. Lawrence 4-2 Cornell
- 1993 : Clarkson 3-1 Brown
- 1994 : Harvard 3-0 Rensselaer
- 1995 : Rensselaer 5-1 Princeton
- 1996 : Cornell 2-1 Harvard
- 1997 : Cornell 2-1 Clarkson
- 1998 : Princeton 5-4 (ot) Clarkson
- 1999 : Clarkson 3-2 St. Lawrence
- 2000 : St. Lawrence 2-0 Rensselaer
- 2001 : St. Lawrence 3-1 Cornell
- 2002 : Harvard 4-3 (2ot) Cornell
- 2003 : Cornell 3-2 (ot) Harvard
- 2004 : Harvard 4-2 Clarkson
- 2005 : Cornell 3-1 Harvard
- 2006 : Harvard 6-2 Cornell
- 2007 : Clarkson 4-2 Quinnipiac
|